Good idea, bad idea
There’s finally a new reality show in the Netherlands, the one everyone was waiting for. In “De Grote Donorshow”, produced by Dutch entertainment giant Endemol (which gifted us with “Big Brother” and a large number of other formats, and is now owned by the Italian group Mediaset), a 37-year old woman suffering from an inoperable brain tumor will choose the recipient for one of her kidneys among three contestants, helped by votes from viewers sent by SMS text messages. Congratulations, the idea is horrible. It doesn’t really matter that the purported intention of the show is to draw attention toward the problem of the very long waiting lists for transplants (there are dozens of better ways to do so); it doesn’t come as a surprise, and at this point it doesn’t matter either, that there’s no guarantee the “winner” will be found compatible with the donated organ, and thus no guarantee that he or she will be able to receive it. But it’s all in the interest of entertainment, right?
The only piece of good news I can see in this is the statement from Education Minister Ronald Plasterk, who said that while the show is “unfitting and unethical”, it’s not up to the government to stop it, as that would constitute an act of censorship. Compare that statement to the behavior of the whole world of Italian politics and its attempts to preempt the broadcasting of the BBC documentary “Sex crimes and the Vatican” (about the Crimen Sollicitationis document, on the policies to follow in matters of child abuse) by the informational program Annozero on Italian national television (scheduled for tonight).
Edited on June 1 at 3:40 PM to add: the documentary was in the end aired during Annozero, against the will of all those who tried to censor it.
Edited on June 2 at 4:20 PM to add: the Dutch reality show turned out to be a hoax and the terminally ill woman turned out to be an actress. However, it seems the three contestants are real people who are really looking for a kidney donor, and just as real were the SMS messages sent during the show’s airtime. My opinion on the matter doesn’t change: there are much better ways to draw attention to the problem of the lack of available organs.
Share This
I’ve (re-)read
More and more families have problems making it to the end of the month.
I love old computer games. I can’t forget the discovery of whole worlds through the creations of some of the greatest minds in the field of gaming: 